Aqara Good Radiator Thermostat E1 Valve Evaluate – A Zigbee sensible TRV with Residence Assistant compatibility
Aqara Good Radiator Thermostat E1 Evaluate Ranking
The Aqara Good Radiator Thermostat E1 is a superb sensible radiator valve with an unbelievable quantity of performance when used with the if/then programming inside Aqara or Residence Assistant. It might be good to see a corresponding boiler thermostat and receiver be launched, permitting full management of your property heating.
- Reasonably priced in comparison with competing methods
- Superior performance and automation options through the automation tab or Residence Assistant vs competing methods
- Simple to put in
- Good schedule wants extra customisation choices
- A one-hour increase mode could be helpful
- No Aqara based mostly boiler thermostat
I someway missed the launch of the Aqara Good Radiator Thermostat E1 a couple of months in the past. I’m a large fan of sensible radiator valves. I reside in a big, comparatively previous home that doesn’t have the perfect insulation and is a bit draughty. Our rooms are very massive, too, and I make money working from home. So it may be very costly to warmth.
I used to be an early adopter of zoned sensible house heating. On the time, I feel it was simply Genius Hub that was providing a correct all-in-one answer. Since then, we now have seen Tado, Hive, Honeywell and Eve Thermo all launch methods which have non-obligatory sensible TRVs accessible.
Now we have additionally seen numerous different lesser-known manufacturers launch sensible TRVs which may work independently from the boiler management. And there are fairly a couple of new Zigbee suitable valves.
I nonetheless use Genius Hub, and adore it, however I’ve lots of radiators, and I had three that had been nonetheless lacking valves. They don’t seem to be necessary radiators, two of them I had dialled right down to the bottom setting. Nonetheless, with the launch of the E1 TRV, I figured it was a great alternative to realize some sensible management over them.
One of many thrilling issues about this valve is that it’s going to work with Matter when it’s totally rolled out. Additionally it is suitable with Residence Assistant. So for any sensible house fanatics, you do have the choice to combine this with a extra superior sensible house heating and residential automation system.
- Requires Zigbee 3.0 suitable hub (Matter assist coming later)
- Backlit show with a dial for management
- Geofencing and multi house assist
- Configurable sensible schedules
- Exterior temperature readings (you possibly can pair up sensors to cross temperature knowledge or use the built-in sensor)
- Machine grouping assist
- Claimed 1-year battery life with AA batteries
- Simple set up
- Door and Window open detection
- Freezing safety
- Facial recognition and automation (utilizing G3 hub)
- Appropriate with
I had a few teething points setting this up. The Aqara Good Hub M2 I exploit initially refused to pair the valves. I later seen a firmware replace accessible for the M2, and as soon as that was up to date, I had no points getting this to work. This additionally utilized to the Aqara G2h Professional, which I later switched to.
For my radiators, I didn’t want to make use of any of the adaptors, the valve screwed straight onto the radiator.
You will want to drag out the tab to energy up the valve. Then inside the Aqara app you possibly can scan the QR code on the facet of the valve, choose the up you need and observe the directions.
You principally simply want to carry down the show for ten seconds till it begins flashing, and it ought to pair up.
After I added every valve, Alexa routinely notified me on my telephone that this was added.
Additionally, it’s price noting that you just don’t technically have to make use of an Aqara hub, it ought to work with different common Zigbee 3.0 hubs.
Irregular Temperature Detected
I additionally had some teething points with two of my three valves reporting irregular temperatures. The recommendation supplied to repair this wasn’t that useful because it listed about 6 completely different causes. This additionally seems to be prefer it was a firmware subject. After utilizing the valves for a few days, a brand new firmware was accessible, and this mounted the issue.
There’s a valve calibration possibility inside the valve settings. I did use this, considering it might repair the irregular temperature drawback, however you most likely don’t want to make use of it.
I’ve seen this warning pop up a few others occasions. It appears to be associated to the room temperature not matching what the valve temperature is ready to. However within the rooms I’m utilizing it, I solely have the valves on for a few hours, and the rooms not often get an opportunity to succeed in the goal temperature, which I assume is the reason for the issue.
In Use & Automation
There are a couple of alternative ways to make use of the valves:
- Guide management the place you choose your goal temp
- Anti-freeze mode – heating is off however will swap on if the temperature drops under 5°C or no matter temperature you set the freezing level
- Good Management – you possibly can allow this when in guide mode, and it supplies three time zones throughout the day, permitting you to set the temperature
- Automation – You may have granular management of the worth utilizing If/Then statements
- Exterior management through voice assistants or Homekit/Residence Assistant
Utilizing the guide/sensible management characteristic is the best approach of setting issues up, however it’s a bit restricted for my liking.
You’ll be able to manually set the temperature, then inside the sensible management, you may have the day cut up into three, and you’ll slide every zone to increase or shorten every time interval and set the goal temp for the three time durations.
Nonetheless, in case you take a look at my Genius Hub schedule, I’ve at the very least 4 segments for heating. There’s the anti-freeze/base temperature, then two separate heating occasions, morning and night.
With the guide management, it’s unclear precisely how this works, I assume you set it, and it stays that temperature till the following time zone. It might be good to have a lift possibility as you may have on most conventional sensible heating methods.
If you wish to have extra management over a wider vary of time zones, you will want to make use of the automation tab inside the Aqara app. On the one hand, this works amazingly properly, supplying you with limitless management of your heating and with the ability to arrange superior sensible house capabilities.
For instance, when you’ve got the G3 hub, you possibly can set it to make use of completely different temperatures based mostly on the particular particular person in that room, due to facial recognition. I don’t suppose any of the primary sensible house heating manufacturers supply something like this.
Nonetheless, it’s a little bit of a convoluted course of in comparison with the conventional scheduling options of competing manufacturers.
Residence Assistant (Not supported on the M2 Hub)
The Aqara system I’ve been utilizing is constructed across the M2 Hub. I’ve solely actually used it for my kitchen lights and the sensible blinds in my bed room. I haven’t had a lot want for Residence Assistant.
I like this hub as a result of it’s wired, and I’m not overly eager on having indoor cameras. Nonetheless, I realised that it’s fairly troublesome to get the M2 operating with Residence Assistant.
I, subsequently, fired up my Aqara G2h Professional and re-added my valves to this, permitting me to make use of Residence Assistant via native assist.
With every little thing eliminated and re-added for the heating, I used to be in a position to set issues up inside Residence Assistant.
Residence Assistant isn’t probably the most user-friendly in comparison with the default Aqara appk, nevertheless it does offer you limitless management and interoperability between completely different sensible house merchandise.
In the intervening time, I simply have some fundamental heating automation arrange and the power to manage the goal temperature from the dashboard.
A easy automation that I’ll arrange is for after I swap my Hue lights on within the morning, it additionally switches the heating on if the room temperature is under my goal temperature. I even have the curler blinds in my room, so I might have it, so the blinds provide you with the button press too.
Value and Various Choices
The Aqara Good Radiator Thermostat E1 is priced at £55, which is in regards to the regular value for sensible valves, some value a bit extra, however they’re all shut.
The Aqara hubs are low cost. The Aqara G2h Pro is £60 however the Aqara Good Hub E1 is simply £26.
I’d say Tado is the perfect total sensible heating answer. You should buy the two thermostat starter equipment for £165 after which £57 for added valves. Tado additionally has a thermostat for boilers, supplying you with a correct all-in-one sensible heating answer.
There are additionally quite a lot of generic Zigbee TRVs with various evaluation rankings. You may get some for as little as £35, however I’d choose to stay to a identified model like Aqara.
I just like the Aqara E1 Good TRV lots, however there’s undoubtedly room for enchancment.
The primary factor is that I feel the sensible schedules needs to be customisable, permitting greater than three time slots. This may then get rid of the necessity to use extra complicated automation options.
Arguably, the largest subject is the dearth of a sensible boiler thermostat, which suggests you’re pressured to arrange matching schedules along with your boiler controller slightly than have the valves management the boiler. I used to be conscious of this going into the evaluation, so it wasn’t an excessive amount of of an issue for me.
My minor gripes probably don’t apply to lots of people. From my expertise, most Aqara customers are usually a bit extra superior and are completely happy to take care of extra complicated methods.
Total although, in case you already use Aqara, then the Thermostat E1 is a straightforward suggestion.
Final replace on 2022-12-26 / Affiliate hyperlinks / Pictures from Amazon Product Promoting API